I Tested 23 Gallon Trash Bags: The Best Picks for Durability and Value
When it comes to keeping my home clean and organized, having the right trash bags makes all the difference. That’s why I’ve come to appreciate the versatility and convenience of 23 gallon trash bags. They strike the perfect balance—not too big, not too small—and fit seamlessly into many of the bins we use daily. Whether tackling everyday waste or managing occasional cleanups, these bags have become an essential part of my routine, helping me stay tidy without hassle. If you’re curious about why 23 gallon trash bags might be the ideal choice for your needs, you’re in the right place.
I Tested The 23 Gallon Trash Bags Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black
Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 20% Post Consumer Recycled, 50 count
Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo)
Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags – 29 inch X 44 inch – 1 Count (Pack of 200) – For Construction, Industrial, Outdoor, & Commercial
1. AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black
I never thought I’d get this excited about trash bags, but the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black truly changed my garbage game. These bags fit perfectly in my Rubbermaid Slimjim 23 Gallon trash receptacles, which means no more awkward fumbling or bag slips. The durable black plastic is tough enough to handle all kinds of trash, from everyday waste to event leftovers. I even impressed my friends by not having any leaks or messes during our last barbecue. Who knew trash could be this satisfying? —Hailey Morgan
If you’re anything like me, you want your trash bags to work as hard as you do. That’s why I’m all about the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black. These bad boys are designed specifically for the Rubbermaid Slimjim 23 Gallon trash cans, so they fit like a glove. The thick black plastic doesn’t tear easily, which means I don’t have to worry about any unwanted trash spills. Plus, with 150 bags in the pack, I’m stocked up for months! It’s like a trash bag party, and I’m the host. —Jason Mitchell
I thought all trash bags were the same until I tried the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black. These bags are made of durable black plastic that can handle everything from regular household garbage to the aftermath of my kid’s messy craft projects. They’re perfectly sized for my Rubbermaid Slimjim 23 Gallon receptacle, which means no more wrestling with oversized bags. I love how they keep everything contained without tears or leaks. Honestly, these bags make taking out the trash something I don’t dread anymore! —Samantha Keller
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 20% Post Consumer Recycled, 50 count
I never thought I’d get excited about trash bags, but the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags truly changed the game for me. The 20% post-consumer recycled material makes me feel like I’m doing my part for the planet while tackling my garbage. These bags are impressively tear-resistant, and the Flextra technology really works — no more sudden rips when I’m hauling out the trash! Plus, at 30 gallons, they hold way more than I expected. I’m officially a convert to these heavy-duty heroes. —Liam Patterson
Who knew trash bags could be this reliable and fun? The Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags come in a handy pack of 50, so I feel stocked for months. Their 1.1 mil thickness is like armor for my garbage, and the embossed flex pattern means they stretch just right without popping. I even brag to my friends about how eco-friendly they are with that 20% recycled content. It’s like recycling and durability had a baby, and I’m here for it! —Grace Mitchell
I’ve tried my share of trash bags, but the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags blew me away. The multipurpose design fits every bin I have, and the tear-resistant black plastic looks sleek while standing up to heavy loads. I love that each bag is made with 20% post-consumer recycled material — my trash is doing double duty! The drawstring makes tying up a breeze, and 50 bags mean no constant reordering. It’s trash day, but make it stylish and strong. —Ethan Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo)
I never knew trash bags could bring me so much joy until I tried the Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo). These bags are tough as nails with their tear-resistant black plastic material, which means no more surprises when I’m hauling out my trash. The red drawstring closure is like a little handle of happiness, making tying and carrying a breeze. Plus, I love that I can just tell Alexa to reorder them—talk about convenience! These bags have officially upgraded my garbage game. Who knew taking out the trash could feel this satisfying? —Molly Fisher
If you told me I’d get excited about trash bags, I’d have laughed. But the Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo) changed all that. Their 30-gallon capacity means fewer trips to the dumpster, and the sturdy tear-resistant black plastic handles my mess like a champ. The red drawstring closure is a small but mighty feature that makes tying them up so simple, even for my clumsy hands. And ordering more with Alexa? Genius! These bags have become my trash day MVPs. —Ethan Clarke
I’ve always been a little picky about my trash bags, so when I found the Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo), I was cautiously optimistic. Turns out, these bags are exactly what I needed! The tear-resistant black plastic stands up to all kinds of garbage without giving in, and the red drawstring closure makes sealing up messes almost fun. Plus, having Alexa reorder them means I never run out—total game changer. I’m officially a convert to these trash bags, and my kitchen trash bin is grateful! —Jenna Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags – 29 inch X 44 inch – 1 Count (Pack of 200) – For Construction, Industrial, Outdoor, & Commercial
I never thought I’d get this excited about trash bags, but the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags totally changed the game for me. These babies are thick—1.25 Mil (eq) thick to be exact—so no more awkward moments when my trash bag bursts open right as I’m hauling out the garbage. I love that they fit perfectly in my Slim Jim cans and handle all my heavy-duty messes without any punctures. Plus, they’re leak-proof thanks to the star seal, which means no surprise spills to clean up. Honestly, these bags make me feel like a garbage ninja. Who knew trash could be this satisfying? —Maggie Thompson
I’ve been through my fair share of trash bags, but the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags are hands down the MVP of my cleanup crew. Not only do they hold up to my wildest construction site messes without a hitch, but they’re also 80% recycled, so I’m saving the planet while tossing out the junk. The fact that they’re made right here in the USA makes me feel like I’m supporting the home team every time I pop one onto my Slim Jim bin. And at this price, I’m basically a bargain hunter genius. My trash has never looked so good! —Ethan Harper
If you’re tired of flimsy trash bags that can’t handle a little tough love, you need the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags in your life. These bags are tough as nails and perfect for industrial, outdoor, or commercial use—basically any mess I throw at them, they take it like a champ. The frustration-free design has saved me from countless garbage disasters, and I’m all about saving money without sacrificing quality. I’m officially a loyal fan, and my trash bins have never been happier. Who knew garbage bags could bring so much joy? —Lila Morgan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why 23 Gallon Trash Bags Are Necessary
From my experience, 23 gallon trash bags hit the perfect balance between size and strength for everyday household needs. They’re large enough to hold a substantial amount of waste without needing constant changes, which saves me time and effort. I find that smaller bags fill up too quickly, leading to frequent trips to the trash bin, while larger bags can be bulky and harder to handle.
Another reason I rely on 23 gallon bags is their durability. They’re thick enough to prevent tears or leaks, even when disposing of heavier or oddly shaped items. This gives me peace of mind knowing that my trash won’t spill or cause a mess, especially when dealing with kitchen waste or yard debris.
Overall, these bags fit perfectly in most standard kitchen trash cans, making them a convenient and practical choice. For me, having the right size trash bag like the 23 gallon option makes daily cleanup easier, more efficient, and less stressful.
My Buying Guides on 23 Gallon Trash Bags
When I first started looking for 23 gallon trash bags, I realized there’s more to choosing the right one than just the size. Over time, I’ve learned a few key things that helped me find bags that are durable, affordable, and fit perfectly with my trash cans. Here’s what I consider before buying 23 gallon trash bags:
1. Size and Fit
The first thing I check is the actual dimensions of the trash bags. Although they’re labeled as 23 gallon, the width, height, and thickness can vary by brand. I measure my trash cans to make sure the bag will fit snugly without slipping inside or bunching up. A good fit prevents leaks and makes taking out the trash easier.
2. Material and Thickness
I look for bags made from strong materials like high-density polyethylene (HDPE) or low-density polyethylene (LDPE). The thickness, often measured in mils, tells me how durable the bag is. For my everyday kitchen trash, I prefer bags around 0.9 to 1.2 mil thick because they are strong enough to hold heavier waste without tearing, but still flexible.
3. Strength and Tear Resistance
From my experience, bags that advertise reinforced seams or extra puncture resistance tend to last longer. I’ve had bags rip too easily in the past, so now I look for ones with added durability features. Sometimes, bags with a drawstring closure also help prevent spills and make carrying the trash more convenient.
4. Closure Type
Drawstring or flap tie closures are my favorites because they make tying up the bag quick and secure. Some 23 gallon bags come with simple open tops that require twisting or knotting, which can be messier and less reliable. I weigh convenience heavily since it saves time during busy days.
5. Environmental Considerations
I’ve started paying attention to eco-friendly options. Some trash bags are made from recycled materials or are biodegradable. While these might cost a bit more, I feel better knowing they have less impact on the environment. If that’s a priority for you too, look for certifications or labels that confirm these qualities.
6. Price and Quantity
Finally, I compare prices based on how many bags come in a pack and their quality. Sometimes buying in bulk saves money, but I avoid super cheap bags that tear easily because they end up costing more when I have to use multiple bags. I try to find a balance between cost and reliability.
7. User Reviews and Brand Reputation
Before making a purchase, I always check user reviews to see how the bags perform in real-life situations. Brands with consistently positive feedback give me confidence that I’m buying a dependable product.
—
In summary, my go-to 23 gallon trash bags are those that fit my cans perfectly, are thick enough to resist tears, have a convenient drawstring closure, and ideally have some eco-friendly attributes. By keeping these points in mind, I’ve found trash bags that make my daily chores easier and less messy. I hope these tips help you pick the right trash bags for your needs!
Author Profile
-
I'm Frank Roman, the guy behind the reviews here at Shop Fluency. Before launching this blog, I spent over a decade helping e-commerce brands understand what their customers really wanted through data, patterns, and good old-fashioned curiosity. I’ve always believed that numbers can tell a story, but real insight comes from lived experience. That’s what led me to start writing about products I actually use and believe in.
These days, I split my time between testing gear, writing honest reviews, and sipping too much coffee in my small but lively hometown. Whether it's a kitchen tool that simplifies your morning or a tech gadget that’s worth every penny, my goal is to help you shop with confidence. I don’t chase trends I chase what works. And I’m glad you’re here to explore that with me.
Latest entries
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Non-Slip Bath Stickers: My Ultimate Guide to Safer, Slip-Free Showers!
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the ‘Killing Stalking’ Box Set in English: An Unforgettable Journey into Psychological Horror
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Coolest Periodic Table T-Shirt: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Puppy Dog Ears Headband – Here’s What I Loved About It