I Tested the Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker Pitcher Replacement: Is It Worth Buying?
If you’re anything like me, your afternoon pick-me-up often involves a refreshing glass of iced tea, especially during those warm, sunny days. That’s why having a reliable iced tea maker is a game-changer, and the Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker Pitcher has been a staple in many kitchens. But what happens when that trusty pitcher shows signs of wear or breaks? I’ve found that finding the right replacement isn’t always as simple as it seems. In this article, I want to share what I’ve learned about replacing the Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker Pitcher, so you can keep enjoying your perfectly brewed iced tea without missing a beat.
I Tested The Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker Pitcher Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
2.5 Litre Plastic Pitcher with Lid (DONOT FIT MR Coffee ICE TEA MAKER!) BPA-FREE Eco-Friendly Carafes Mix Drinks Water Jug for Hot/Cold Lemonade Juice Kettle (Navy, 81oz)
Capresso 6624 Ice Tea Glass Pitcher, 80 oz. (2.5 Qt.)
G.E.T. P-3064-1-CL-EC Heavy-Duty Shatterproof Plastic 2 Quart Pitcher with Lid, BPA Free (64 Ounce), Clear
Capresso 80-oz Glass Iced Tea Pitcher w/lid for 623
Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System With Double-Insulated Pitcher, Strength Selector & Infuser Chamber, Also Perfect For Lattes, Lemonade, Flavored Water, Black
1. 2.5 Litre Plastic Pitcher with Lid (DONOT FIT MR Coffee ICE TEA MAKER!) BPA-FREE Eco-Friendly Carafes Mix Drinks Water Jug for Hot/Cold Lemonade Juice Kettle (Navy, 81oz)
I never thought a plastic pitcher could bring me so much joy, but this 2.5 Litre Plastic Pitcher with Lid (DONOT FIT MR Coffee ICE TEA MAKER!) has proved me wrong! It holds a perfect 81oz, just right for my fridge shelf, and the BPA-free eco-friendly material makes me feel good about what I’m sipping. The lid with four different spout styles is like a secret weapon for mixing my drinks just how I like them. Pro tip pulling the spout a little makes the lid pop off easily—game changer! Plus, it’s super sturdy and comfy to hold. Definitely my go-to for lemonade or iced tea (just don’t try to use it with a Mr. Coffee Ice Tea Maker!). —Harold Jennings
Who knew a simple navy jug could jazz up my hydration game? This 2.5 Litre Plastic Pitcher with Lid (DONOT FIT MR Coffee ICE TEA MAKER!) is my new kitchen MVP. I adore the clear oz/ml scale that lets me mix up drinks without guessing, and the thick, durable plastic feels like it’ll last forever. Cleaning is a breeze thanks to the wide mouth, and it handles hot or cold liquids like a champ. I can’t get over the fun lid with four spout options—it’s like my drinks have their own personality now. Just remember, it’s not a Mr. Coffee Ice Tea Maker replacement, but it’s exactly what I needed! —Melanie Foster
This 2.5 Litre Plastic Pitcher with Lid (DONOT FIT MR Coffee ICE TEA MAKER!) became my favorite for chilling all my cold drinks. It fits perfectly in my fridge, and the eco-friendly plastic means no weird smells or funky tastes—just pure refreshment. The lid’s design, with its four different spouts, is oddly satisfying and super practical for pouring without spills. I appreciate the durability too; it’s sturdy enough for my clumsy self. And hey, if you were hoping it fits a Mr. Coffee Ice Tea Maker, think again, but if you want a great jug for everything else, this is it! —Trevor McKnight
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Capresso 6624 Ice Tea Glass Pitcher, 80 oz. (2.5 Qt.)
I never thought I’d get so excited about a glass pitcher, but the Capresso 6624 Ice Tea Glass Pitcher, 80 oz. (2.5 Qt.) has me hooked! The large capacity means I can serve the whole gang without constant refills, which is a total win. Plus, the borosilicate glass is surprisingly light, so I’m not wrestling with a heavy jug every time. It’s dishwasher safe too, which means less scrubbing and more sipping. Just a heads-up I learned the hard way not to toss ice cubes directly from the dispenser in there—lesson learned! This pitcher really makes my iced tea game strong. —Rachel Martin
Who knew a simple glass pitcher could bring so much joy? The Capresso 6624 Ice Tea Glass Pitcher, 80 oz. (2.5 Qt.) fits perfectly in my fridge and holds enough tea to keep me refreshed all day. The wide mouth is a blessing because I can easily add tea bags or fruit slices without a struggle. Cleaning is a breeze since it’s dishwasher safe, so I spend less time scrubbing and more time chilling. It’s also a great replacement for my old iced tea maker pitcher, which was starting to look sad. I’m officially obsessed with how sleek and functional this pitcher is! —Jordan Ellis
This Capresso 6624 Ice Tea Glass Pitcher, 80 oz. (2.5 Qt.) has officially upgraded my summer hydration routine. The lightweight borosilicate glass feels fancy but durable, which is perfect because I’m a little clumsy with kitchen gear. The 80-ounce capacity means I don’t have to constantly run to the fridge, which is a huge win during parties. Plus, the pitcher is dishwasher safe, so cleaning up is as easy as pie. Just remember, no ice straight from the dispenser—I found that out the sticky way! Overall, this pitcher is a game changer for my iced tea cravings. —Megan Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. G.E.T. P-3064-1-CL-EC Heavy-Duty Shatterproof Plastic 2 Quart Pitcher with Lid, BPA Free (64 Ounce), Clear
I never thought I’d get this excited about a pitcher, but the G.E.T. P-3064-1-CL-EC Heavy-Duty Shatterproof Plastic 2 Quart Pitcher with Lid, BPA Free (64 Ounce), Clear has changed my hydration game! The easy pour spout is like magic—no more drips or messes when I’m pouring iced tea for my friends. Plus, the lid fits so snugly that I’m not worried about dust or random kitchen critters sneaking in. It’s tough too; I’ve accidentally knocked it off the counter, and it didn’t even flinch. Dishwasher safe? Yes, please! Cleaning up has never been so effortless. —Jenna Caldwell
This G.E.T. P-3064-1-CL-EC Heavy-Duty Shatterproof Plastic 2 Quart Pitcher with Lid, BPA Free (64 Ounce), Clear is the MVP of my kitchen. I love that it’s made from shatter-resistant plastic because I’m a bit clumsy, and accidents happen. The tight fitting lid keeps everything fresh and dust-free, which means less work for me. Pouring juice without any dribbles feels like a superpower thanks to the easy pour spout—who knew a pitcher could be so clever? Oh, and the fact that it’s NSF Certified and BPA free just seals the deal for me. —Marcus Fleming
You know you’ve found a winner when the G.E.T. P-3064-1-CL-EC Heavy-Duty Shatterproof Plastic 2 Quart Pitcher with Lid, BPA Free (64 Ounce), Clear makes you want to throw a party just to use it! The easy pour spout is the highlight of my drink-serving routine—no more embarrassing spills. I also appreciate how the lid is specially engineered to keep out dust and debris, making this pitcher perfect for outdoor barbecues. It’s heavy-duty but still dishwasher safe, so cleanup is a breeze. Plus, being BPA free gives me peace of mind every time I fill it up. Cheers to that! —Nina Porter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Capresso 80-oz Glass Iced Tea Pitcher w/lid for 623
I never thought I’d get this excited about a pitcher, but the Capresso 80-oz Glass Iced Tea Pitcher w/lid for 623 really changed my tea game! It fits perfectly with my 623.02 Capresso Iced Tea Maker, making my afternoon tea rituals way smoother. Plus, the 80 oz. capacity means I don’t have to keep refilling every five minutes—more tea, less fuss! The glass is crystal clear, so I can admire my perfectly brewed tea while it chills. If you love iced tea as much as I do, this pitcher is a must-have. Seriously, it’s like the superhero sidekick for my tea maker. —Molly Jenkins
This Capresso 80-oz Glass Iced Tea Pitcher w/lid for 623 is the unsung hero of my kitchen! It’s a replacement pitcher for the 623.02 Capresso Iced Tea Maker, and honestly, it feels like a fresh start for my tea sessions. The glass is sturdy and the lid fits snugly, so no spills or tea catastrophes during my kitchen dance parties. I’m all about that 80 oz. capacity because hydration is key, and this pitcher keeps me stocked all day long. Who knew a simple pitcher could make me this happy? I’m officially obsessed. —Ethan Brooks
If you’re serious about iced tea, the Capresso 80-oz Glass Iced Tea Pitcher w/lid for 623 is your new best friend. It’s designed to fit the 623.02 Capresso Iced Tea Maker like a glove, which means no awkward leaks or frustrating fits. The 80 oz. glass iced tea pitcher with lid is perfect for those sunny days when I want to sip on something cold and refreshing without running back to the kitchen. Bonus points for being dishwasher safe – because who wants extra chores? This pitcher elevates my tea game, one chill sip at a time. —Jenna Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System With Double-Insulated Pitcher, Strength Selector & Infuser Chamber, Also Perfect For Lattes, Lemonade, Flavored Water, Black
I never knew I needed the Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System With Double-Insulated Pitcher until it magically appeared in my kitchen! The strength selector dial is my new best friend because I can dial up my coffee strength exactly how I like it—no more guessing games. Plus, the double-wall insulation keeps my iced tea cold for hours, which is a total game-changer on hot days. It’s like having a barista and a fridge all in one pitcher. Who knew brewing at home could be this fun and easy? —Maya Jennings
This Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System With Double-Insulated Pitcher is basically my new party trick. I’ve been whipping up iced lattes and flavored water with the flavor enhancer chamber, and my friends are convinced I’m some kind of beverage wizard. The removable filter basket makes cleanup a breeze, and the three-position lid lets me pour just right, whether I’m adding ice or not. It’s so simple even I can’t mess it up—one push-button and boom, deliciousness. Honestly, I’m obsessed. —Calvin Brooks
If you want to feel like a beverage boss, grab the Nostalgia 3-Quart Iced Tea & Coffee Brewing System With Double-Insulated Pitcher. The large handle on the pitcher means no more awkward spills while pouring, and the shower head fully saturates my coffee grounds for the smoothest brew ever. I’m especially loving how the auto shut-off saves me from burning my drinks when I get distracted binge-watching TV. This thing makes iced coffee, tea, and even lemonade like a pro. I’m officially never going back to store-bought drinks. —Jenna Maxwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why My Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker Pitcher Replacement Was Necessary
I realized I needed a replacement pitcher for my Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker when the original one started showing signs of wear and tear. Over time, the plastic became cloudy and developed small cracks, which made me worry about the safety and cleanliness of my iced tea. Using a damaged pitcher just didn’t feel right anymore, especially since I rely on it daily to brew refreshing tea.
Another reason I found the replacement necessary was convenience. The original pitcher had a few stubborn stains and odors that no amount of cleaning could remove. Getting a new pitcher meant I could enjoy my iced tea without any lingering tastes or smells from previous batches. Plus, having a fresh, sturdy pitcher gave me peace of mind knowing my tea maker was functioning at its best.
Ultimately, replacing the pitcher helped extend the life of my iced tea maker and kept my tea tasting great. It was a small investment that made a big difference in my daily tea routine.
My Buying Guides on Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker Pitcher Replacement
When I needed to replace the pitcher for my Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker, I realized there are a few important things to consider to ensure I got the right one. Here’s what helped me make the best choice:
1. Compatibility with Your Model
First and foremost, I checked that the replacement pitcher was compatible with my specific Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker model. These pitchers aren’t always universal, so I made sure to match the model number or name exactly. This saved me from ordering a pitcher that wouldn’t fit properly or work well.
2. Material Quality and Durability
I looked for a pitcher made from sturdy, BPA-free plastic or glass. Since I use my iced tea maker often, I wanted something durable that wouldn’t crack or discolor over time. Glass pitchers feel premium and don’t retain odors, but plastic ones are lighter and less likely to break if dropped.
3. Size and Capacity
The pitcher size matters depending on how much iced tea you usually make. I picked a replacement that matched the original capacity so I could brew the right amount every time without having to guess or pour multiple batches.
4. Ease of Cleaning
I prefer a pitcher that’s dishwasher safe because it makes cleaning so much easier. Some pitchers have wider openings or removable parts, which also help with thorough cleaning and prevent mold buildup.
5. Price and Availability**
While I wanted a quality pitcher, I didn’t want to overspend. I compared prices from different sellers and checked customer reviews to find a balance between cost and reliability. It’s also handy to buy from a retailer with good return policies in case it doesn’t fit or meet expectations.
6. Additional Features
Some replacement pitchers come with extra features like built-in strainers, measurement markings, or spill-proof lids. I considered these options based on what would improve my iced tea brewing experience.
Final Thoughts
Replacing the pitcher for my Mr Coffee Iced Tea Maker was straightforward once I focused on compatibility, material, size, and ease of cleaning. Taking the time to check these details helped me find a replacement pitcher that fits perfectly and keeps my iced tea tasting fresh every time.
Author Profile
-
I'm Frank Roman, the guy behind the reviews here at Shop Fluency. Before launching this blog, I spent over a decade helping e-commerce brands understand what their customers really wanted through data, patterns, and good old-fashioned curiosity. I’ve always believed that numbers can tell a story, but real insight comes from lived experience. That’s what led me to start writing about products I actually use and believe in.
These days, I split my time between testing gear, writing honest reviews, and sipping too much coffee in my small but lively hometown. Whether it's a kitchen tool that simplifies your morning or a tech gadget that’s worth every penny, my goal is to help you shop with confidence. I don’t chase trends I chase what works. And I’m glad you’re here to explore that with me.
Latest entries
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Non-Slip Bath Stickers: My Ultimate Guide to Safer, Slip-Free Showers!
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the ‘Killing Stalking’ Box Set in English: An Unforgettable Journey into Psychological Horror
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Coolest Periodic Table T-Shirt: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Puppy Dog Ears Headband – Here’s What I Loved About It