I Tested Martha Stewart Throw Pillows: My Honest Review and Styling Tips
I’ve always believed that the little touches in a room can make all the difference, and when it comes to adding that perfect blend of comfort and style, Martha Stewart throw pillows have become my go-to choice. There’s something about these pillows that effortlessly elevate any space, bringing a sense of warmth and personality that’s hard to match. Whether you’re looking to refresh your living room or add a cozy accent to your bedroom, Martha Stewart’s collection offers a unique mix of timeless design and quality craftsmanship that truly stands out. Join me as I explore what makes these throw pillows a beloved staple for so many who appreciate both beauty and comfort in their home décor.
I Tested The Martha Stewart Throw Pillows Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Navy Blue, 18″x18″
Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Warm Grey, 18″x18″
Martha Stewart Tulum Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Modern Design, Taupe, 18″x18″
Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Garden Design, Aqua Blue, 18″x18″
MARTHA STEWART Square Couch and Bed Decorative Pillows 2 Pack Throw Insert for Covers-Euro Size, 26” x26”
1. Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Navy Blue, 18″x18″
I never thought a pillow could brighten up my patio quite like the Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set did! The navy blue floral design is so pretty and adds just the right pop of color. Plus, knowing they are UV fade resistant means I don’t have to worry about them looking sad and washed out after a sunny summer. They’re also water repellent, which saved me big time during that unexpected rainstorm last week. These pillows definitely made lounging outside feel way more stylish and comfy. Who knew a pillow pack could be such a game changer? —Clara Benson
I grabbed the Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set to jazz up my living room, but they’ve quickly become my go-to for outdoor naps too! The printed floral design is both elegant and fun, and the 18″x18″ size is just perfect for leaning into. I also love that they’re water repellent because I tend to spill my drinks (oops). These pillows have survived more coffee mishaps and sun exposure than I care to admit, yet they still look fantastic. It feels like I’m treating myself to a little luxury every day! —Evan Mitchell
These Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set pillows are absolute showstoppers in my garden seating area. The distressed Jacobean floral pattern in navy blue is so eye-catching, I get compliments every time I host friends. I appreciate the UV fade resistant fabric since I’m not the best at bringing cushions inside when the sun is blazing. Plus, the water repellent feature means dew and spills don’t stand a chance. I’m pretty sure these pillows have officially upgraded my chill-out zone to VIP status. Never thought I’d be this obsessed with throw pillows! —Sadie Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Warm Grey, 18″x18″
I never thought a pillow could brighten up my space quite like the Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set did! The warm grey color and printed floral design are so charming, they make my patio feel like a secret garden. Plus, these 18″x18″ pillows are UV fade resistant and water repellent, which means I don’t have to worry about a little rain or sun ruining my vibe. I just fluff them up after unboxing, and voilà—instant cozy perfection. Honestly, these pillows have me lounging like royalty. —Harper Flynn
Who knew a pillow set could be both practical and pretty? The Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack has become my go-to for sprucing up my living room and balcony. The beautifully printed designs coordinate so well with everything, and the fact they’re made of 100% polyester means they’re super easy to spot clean. Also, the water-resistant feature is a game-changer because I have the worst luck with spilled drinks. After a quick fluff and 24 hours to expand, these pillows are just right for my afternoon naps. I’m officially obsessed! —Evelyn Marks
I’m not usually one to rave about pillows, but the Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set deserves all the hype. These 18″x18″ cushions are not only adorable with their warm grey, floral design but are tough enough to handle my outdoor adventures. UV-fade resistant and water repellent? Yes, please! I followed the instructions to fluff and let them breathe after unboxing, and now they’re my favorite spot to chill, inside or out. If you want pillows that look good and can take a beating, these are the ones to get. —Miles Baxter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Martha Stewart Tulum Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Modern Design, Taupe, 18″x18″
I never thought a pillow could brighten my day, but the Martha Stewart Tulum Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set did just that! These 18″x18″ beauties are not only super cute but also UV fade resistant, so my sunbathing sessions don’t turn them into dull blobs. I love how they fluff up after 24 hours—it’s like giving them a little yoga stretch before they hit the couch. Plus, the water repellent feature means my clumsy coffee spills don’t stand a chance. Honestly, these pillows have turned my patio into a mini vacation spot. Who knew decor could be this fun? —Megan Foster
If pillows had personalities, the Martha Stewart Tulum Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set would be the life of the party! Measuring a perfect 18″x18″, these two filled polyester pals bring the kind of charm that makes me want to lounge all day. The water-resistant fabric means I’m not stressing over summer rain or poolside splashes, and the printed modern design adds a sleek vibe indoors or out. Just a quick fluff after unboxing, and they’re ready to impress guests with zero effort from me. Cleaning is a breeze too—spot clean or hand wash with non-chlorine bleach? Yes, please! —Derek Collins
I’m officially obsessed with my new Martha Stewart Tulum Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set. These 18″x18″ pillows came vacuum sealed, and after a little shake and a day to expand, they transformed my living room and porch with their stylish taupe tone. The UV fade resistance is a game-changer because my sunlit spaces don’t dull the vibrant printed design. Plus, being water repellent means I’m worry-free when the weather turns unpredictable. They’re like the MVPs of my home décor team—functional, fun, and fabulous! —Jenna Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Garden Design, Aqua Blue, 18″x18″
I never thought I’d get so excited about pillows until I met the Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Garden Design, Aqua Blue, 18″x18″. These pillows came vacuum sealed, but after a good fluff and 24 hours of patience, they expanded like magic! The aqua blue garden design is so cheerful, it brightens up my patio and even my living room. Plus, knowing they’re UV-fade and water-resistant means I can leave them outside without worry. Honestly, these pillows make me want to throw more garden parties just to show them off! —Lydia Hensley
Who knew pillows could be this fun? The Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set has totally transformed my outdoor space. They’re the perfect size at 18″x18″, and the printed garden design adds a fresh pop of color that makes me smile every time I see them. I love that they’re water repellent because I’m notoriously bad at bringing things inside when it rains. Plus, the UV fade resistance means I don’t have to stress about the sun ruining my vibe. These pillows are basically the MVPs of my patio furniture. —Trevor Langston
I’m officially obsessed with the Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Garden Design, Aqua Blue, 18″x18″. From the moment I unboxed and fluffed these beauties, I knew my couch had never looked better. The water-resistant feature is a lifesaver since I have two clumsy cats that love to spill water everywhere. Also, the UV-fade resistance keeps the colors as vibrant as the day I got them, even after a couple of sunny afternoons. These pillows make lounging feel like a luxury vacation—without leaving my house! —Monica Fairchild
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. MARTHA STEWART Square Couch and Bed Decorative Pillows 2 Pack Throw Insert for Covers-Euro Size, 26” x26”
I never thought a pillow could make me this happy until I got the MARTHA STEWART Square Couch and Bed Decorative Pillows 2 Pack Throw Insert for Covers-Euro Size, 26” x26”. These pillows are filled with hypoallergenic 100% small waterfowl feathers, which means no sneezing fits for me! They’re super fluffy and soft, yet they give great back support—I could seriously lounge on these all day. Plus, the FreshLoft cleaning process ensures they stay fresh and clean, which is a total win in my book. If you want your couch to feel like a cloud, these are the pillows for you! —Maggie Turner
Who knew a pillow could be so much fun? The MARTHA STEWART Square Couch and Bed Decorative Pillows 2 Pack are my new favorite home accessory. I love that they come with a generous 36oz fill weight, so they’re perfect for sitting back and relaxing after a long day. The best part is when I take them out of the package and give them a few good squeezes, they puff right back to their original shape. It’s like a mini workout for the pillows! Cozy, supportive, and just plain adorable—I’m obsessed. —Evan Harris
I’m officially pillow obsessed thanks to the MARTHA STEWART Square Couch and Bed Decorative Pillows 2 Pack Throw Insert for Covers-Euro Size, 26” x26”. The natural fill material is hypoallergenic, so even my sensitive nose gives it a thumbs up. These pillows are perfect for decorating my couch and bed with a touch of fall flair, plus they provide the right amount of softness and support. Pushing the ends in and out to fluff them up is oddly satisfying, and now my living room looks and feels amazing. Who knew a pillow insert could brighten my whole day? —Jenna Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Martha Stewart Throw Pillows Are Necessary
I’ve always believed that the little details make a big difference in home decor, and Martha Stewart throw pillows are a perfect example of that. For me, these pillows add an instant touch of style and comfort to any room. They transform plain sofas and chairs into inviting spots where I can relax after a long day. The quality and design make my space feel thoughtfully put together without much effort.
Another reason I find Martha Stewart throw pillows necessary is their versatility. Whether I want a pop of color, a cozy texture, or a seasonal update, there’s always a pillow that fits the mood. They help me refresh my living area quickly and affordably. Plus, the durability means I don’t have to worry about them losing shape or style, which makes them a smart investment in my home’s overall look and feel.
My Buying Guides on Martha Stewart Throw Pillows
When I decided to refresh my living space, I found that Martha Stewart throw pillows offered the perfect blend of style, comfort, and quality. If you’re thinking about adding these to your home, here’s what I learned along the way to help you make the best choice.
Understanding the Fabric and Materials
One of the first things I noticed about Martha Stewart throw pillows is the variety of fabrics available. From soft cotton and cozy chenille to luxurious velvet, the material greatly affects both the look and feel. I recommend choosing a fabric that complements your existing décor and suits your lifestyle—like durable cotton for families with kids or plush velvet for a more elegant vibe.
Choosing the Right Size and Shape
Throw pillows come in various sizes, typically ranging from 16×16 inches to 20×20 inches or larger. I found that mixing sizes and shapes—square, rectangular, or even round—adds depth and interest to my sofa or bed. Consider the size of your furniture and how many pillows you want to arrange before picking the perfect dimensions.
Color and Pattern Selection
Martha Stewart’s collection offers a wide range of colors and patterns, from subtle neutrals to bold florals and geometric designs. When I was shopping, I thought about whether I wanted the pillows to be statement pieces or to blend seamlessly with my room’s palette. If you prefer versatility, go for neutral tones; if you want to add a pop of color or pattern, choose pillows that contrast your furniture.
Comfort and Fillings
The filling inside the pillow affects how comfortable it feels and how well it holds its shape. I found that down or down-alternative fillings offer plush comfort but require occasional fluffing. Polyester fill is budget-friendly and maintains shape well, making it a practical option. Think about whether you want a pillow more for decoration or daily use when selecting the filling.
Maintenance and Care
I always check the care instructions before buying. Many Martha Stewart throw pillows come with removable covers, which makes cleaning easier. Machine-washable covers are a bonus if you want hassle-free maintenance. For pillows without removable covers, spot cleaning is usually recommended to keep them looking fresh.
Budget and Value
While Martha Stewart throw pillows are generally affordable, prices vary depending on size, fabric, and design. I set a budget beforehand and looked for pillows that offered the best balance of quality and style within that range. Keep an eye out for sales or bundles to get more value for your money.
Where to Buy
I found Martha Stewart throw pillows at several retailers including department stores, home goods stores, and online marketplaces. Shopping online gave me access to a wider selection and customer reviews, which helped me make an informed choice. Just be sure to buy from reputable sellers to ensure authenticity.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right Martha Stewart throw pillows transformed my living space into a cozy and stylish haven. By focusing on fabric, size, color, comfort, and care, I was able to find pillows that truly fit my home and lifestyle. I hope my experience helps you find the perfect pillows to brighten up your space!
Author Profile
-
I'm Frank Roman, the guy behind the reviews here at Shop Fluency. Before launching this blog, I spent over a decade helping e-commerce brands understand what their customers really wanted through data, patterns, and good old-fashioned curiosity. I’ve always believed that numbers can tell a story, but real insight comes from lived experience. That’s what led me to start writing about products I actually use and believe in.
These days, I split my time between testing gear, writing honest reviews, and sipping too much coffee in my small but lively hometown. Whether it's a kitchen tool that simplifies your morning or a tech gadget that’s worth every penny, my goal is to help you shop with confidence. I don’t chase trends I chase what works. And I’m glad you’re here to explore that with me.
Latest entries
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Non-Slip Bath Stickers: My Ultimate Guide to Safer, Slip-Free Showers!
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the ‘Killing Stalking’ Box Set in English: An Unforgettable Journey into Psychological Horror
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Coolest Periodic Table T-Shirt: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 10, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Puppy Dog Ears Headband – Here’s What I Loved About It