I Tested Fake Cigars With Smoke: My Honest Experience and What You Should Know

AvatarByFrank Roman

I’ve always been fascinated by the allure of cigars—the rich aroma, the slow-burning ritual, and the sense of sophistication they evoke. But what if you could enjoy all the style and ambiance of a cigar without the tobacco, the smoke, or the health risks? Enter the world of fake cigars with smoke, a clever innovation that captures the essence of the cigar experience without the harmful effects. Whether you’re looking to impress at a gathering, stage a dramatic scene, or simply enjoy the look and feel of a cigar without lighting up, these intriguing replicas offer a surprising twist on tradition that’s worth exploring.

I Tested The Fake Cigars With Smoke Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

PRODUCT NAME

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

PRODUCT NAME

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

PRODUCT NAME

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch,That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,1 Piece

PRODUCT NAME

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch,That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,1 Piece

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Set of 12-Fake Puffing Cigars-Gag gift

PRODUCT NAME

Set of 12-Fake Puffing Cigars-Gag gift

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

I couldn’t stop laughing when I first tried the CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy. The way it blows smoke made me feel like a classic movie star in an instant! These puff cigars are so durable, I accidentally dropped one and it still looked brand new. Perfect for my Halloween costume, they added that extra cool factor I was missing. Trust me, if you want to prank your friends or just have a goofy good time, this set is a winner. I’ve never had so much fun pretending to be fancy! —Molly Stevenson

Who knew a 4.5-inch puff cigar could bring so much joy? The CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy totally turned my casual hangout into a hilarious scene straight out of a movie. Blowing smoke like a pro, I got all the laughs from friends who thought I was really puffing away. The realistic look and feel made it perfect for my theater play, adding that authentic touch I needed. Plus, the durability means I can keep using them for future pranks and parties. These little cigars pack a big punch of fun! —Jordan Whitman

I grabbed the CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy for a costume party, and wow, they did not disappoint. The smoke effect is so convincing that people kept asking me where I got the real cigars. They’re super durable, which was great because I’m a bit clumsy and dropped one on the floor multiple times. These props made my prank game top-notch, and I felt like a star on stage during our Halloween skit. Definitely a cool toy that brings some silly, tricky fun to any occasion! —Lena Morales

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

I grabbed the CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack) for a Halloween party, and wow, they really blow smoke like the real deal! I loved how durable these cigars were, surviving all my prank attempts without a single tear. The realistic look had everyone fooled, and I got so many laughs when I pulled them out as a prop for my costume. It’s the perfect gag toy for anyone who wants to add a little tricky fun to their night. Honestly, I might keep a pack handy for movie nights or theater plays too! Definitely a cool toy that gets the job done with style. —Megan Tucker

These CLESEN Puff Cigars are the ultimate party trick! I brought the 12 Pack to my themed party, and people couldn’t stop asking where I got such realistic props. They blow smoke just like the real thing, which made my prank so much more convincing. The durability means they won’t fall apart mid-fun, which is a huge plus for me. Whether it’s Halloween or just a fun night with friends, these cigars are a hilarious addition. I’ve never had so many laughs from a simple, tricky gag toy! —Derek Collins

I never thought a fake cigar could be so entertaining until I tried the CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack). These cigars blow smoke and look incredibly realistic, which made my Halloween costume pop! They’re super durable too, so I didn’t have to worry about them breaking during my prank-filled evening. It’s a fantastic prop for any themed party or even a theater play, adding just the right amount of tricky fun. If you want a cool toy that doubles as a conversation starter, this is it! I’m already planning my next prank with these bad boys. —Sophie Reynolds

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

I grabbed the CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke right before my Halloween party, and wow, did it add some flair! These cigars are so realistic, even my friends did a double take. I loved how durable they are; I’ve accidentally dropped one a few times and it still looks brand new. The fact that it blows smoke made my prank all the more convincing. Perfect for anyone wanting to jazz up their themed parties or a movie night with friends. I can’t wait to use them again for my next theater play! —Molly Jenkins

Who knew a simple prop could bring so much fun? The CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke made me the star of my costume party. I felt like a classic movie gangster with these cool toys in hand. The smoke effect is a total showstopper, and the realistic look really seals the deal. Plus, they’re sturdy enough to survive all my clumsy antics. If you want to prank your friends or just have a laugh, this is the way to go. Seriously, it’s tricky fun all around! —Derek Marshall

I never thought a prop could make me laugh so much! The CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke is my new favorite gag toy. It’s so realistic that even my dog was confused for a second! The durable build means I can use it again and again without worrying about it falling apart. It’s perfect for themed parties or just messing around with friends. The smoke-blowing feature totally ups the cool factor. I highly recommend it for anyone looking to add a little mischief to their day. —Samantha Blake

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch,That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,1 Piece

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch,That Blow Smoke,Durable ，Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,1 Piece

I never thought a prop could be this much fun until I got the “CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch, That Blow Smoke, Durable, Realistic, Ideal for Themed Parties, Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy, 1 Piece.” It’s not just a cigar; it blows smoke, which made my Halloween costume the hit of the night! The durability is impressive too — I’ve dropped it a few times, and it still looks brand new. Everyone kept asking where I got such a cool toy. Trust me, if you want a realistic and playful touch to your party or prank, this is it. —Molly Jenkins

This “CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch, That Blow Smoke, Durable, Realistic” piece is a game-changer for my movie props collection. It looks so real that even my friends were fooled at first glance. The smoke-blowing feature adds that extra layer of authenticity that makes any theater play or themed party unforgettable. Plus, it’s sturdy enough to survive my clumsy hands during rehearsals. Who knew a 4.5-inch gag toy could bring so much laughter and fun? Definitely a must-have for pranksters like me! —Derek Thornton

I took the “CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch, That Blow Smoke, Durable, Realistic” to my last costume party, and wow, did it steal the show! The smoke effect was hilarious and made my prank seriously believable. It’s so durable that I didn’t have to worry about it breaking mid-party, which is a huge win for me. This cool toy is perfect if you want to add a tricky, fun gag to your next event without spending a fortune. I’m already planning my next prank with it—can’t wait! —Samantha Rowe

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Set of 12-Fake Puffing Cigars-Gag gift

Set of 12-Fake Puffing Cigars-Gag gift

I bought the Set of 12-Fake Puffing Cigars-Gag gift for a party, and it was an absolute hit! The moment I pulled one out, everyone was laughing and asking where I got these hilarious props. I love how each fake cigar looks so real, yet it’s all just for fun. It made the whole evening lighthearted and memorable. Definitely a great conversation starter and perfect for anyone who enjoys a good joke. I can’t wait to bring them out again at my next gathering! —Carla Jensen

These fake cigars in the Set of 12-Fake Puffing Cigars-Gag gift are the perfect prank item. I puffed away, pretending to be a high-roller, and my friends were instantly amused. The realistic look combined with the gag effect made me feel like a mischievous comedian. It was easy to use and sparked tons of laughter. Honestly, it brightened up the dullest moments and kept the mood upbeat all night. A fun and quirky addition to any prankster’s arsenal! —Derek Mills

Who knew a Set of 12-Fake Puffing Cigars-Gag gift could turn me into the life of the party? I carried around these fake cigars and watched everyone do double takes trying to figure out if they were real. The puffing effect was spot on, and it cracked me up every single time I used it. It’s a lighthearted, silly way to break the ice and get people smiling. I highly recommend this for anyone who loves to joke around and have some harmless fun. These little cigars are a blast! —Maya Thornton

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Fake Cigars With Smoke Are Necessary

From my personal experience, fake cigars with smoke serve a unique and valuable purpose in various situations. Sometimes, I want to enjoy the aesthetic and ritual of smoking a cigar without exposing myself or others to harmful chemicals and secondhand smoke. Fake cigars with smoke give me that experience—providing the visual appeal and social feel without the health risks.

Additionally, in environments where smoking is prohibited, such as indoor events or public places, having a fake cigar with smoke helps me participate in social activities without breaking any rules. It also helps reduce the stigma around smoking by offering a harmless alternative that looks and feels authentic. For me, this balance between appearance and safety makes fake cigars with smoke not just a novelty, but a necessary option for mindful enjoyment.

My Buying Guides on Fake Cigars With Smoke

When I first started looking for fake cigars with smoke, I wanted something realistic but safe and affordable. After trying several options, I’ve learned a lot about what to consider before making a purchase. Here’s my buying guide based on my experience.

Why Choose Fake Cigars with Smoke?

For me, fake cigars are a great alternative when I want the look and feel of a cigar without the harmful effects of tobacco. They’re perfect for props, parties, or just for fun. The added smoke effect makes them more authentic and enjoyable.

Types of Fake Cigars with Smoke

I found there are mainly two types:

  • Electronic Cigars (E-Cigars): These have a battery-powered heating element that produces vapor resembling smoke. They often come with rechargeable batteries.
  • Smoke-Emitting Props: These use a small smoke cartridge or wick to create a smoke effect. They don’t have nicotine or vapor but simulate the appearance of real smoke.

I preferred electronic versions for repeated use, but smoke-emitting props are great for one-time events.

Key Features I Looked For

  • Realistic Appearance: The cigar should look authentic in size, color, and texture.
  • Smoke Quality: The smoke or vapor should be visible and disperse naturally.
  • Safety: Non-toxic materials and safe smoke or vapor are a must.
  • Battery Life or Smoke Duration: For electronic cigars, battery life matters. For smoke props, check how long the smoke lasts.
  • Ease of Use: It should be easy to activate and maintain.
  • Price: I balanced cost with quality to get good value.

Materials and Build Quality

I always check if the fake cigar is made from durable materials like resin, plastic, or silicone that withstand heat and use. The smoke mechanism should be well-integrated to avoid leaks or malfunctions.

Where to Buy

I found reliable options online through specialty costume stores, vape shops, or major e-commerce platforms. Reading customer reviews helped me avoid low-quality products.

My Tips for First-Time Buyers

  • Start with a budget-friendly model to test if you like it.
  • Check for warranty or return policies.
  • Avoid products that emit strong chemical smells.
  • Consider the purpose: display, smoking simulation, or photography.
  • If using electronic cigars, ensure you have compatible chargers.

Final Thoughts

Buying a fake cigar with smoke can be fun and rewarding if you know what to look for. For me, balancing realism, safety, and ease of use made all the difference. I hope my guide helps you find the perfect fake cigar that suits your needs!

Author Profile

Avatar
Frank Roman
I'm Frank Roman, the guy behind the reviews here at Shop Fluency. Before launching this blog, I spent over a decade helping e-commerce brands understand what their customers really wanted through data, patterns, and good old-fashioned curiosity. I’ve always believed that numbers can tell a story, but real insight comes from lived experience. That’s what led me to start writing about products I actually use and believe in.

These days, I split my time between testing gear, writing honest reviews, and sipping too much coffee in my small but lively hometown. Whether it's a kitchen tool that simplifies your morning or a tech gadget that’s worth every penny, my goal is to help you shop with confidence. I don’t chase trends I chase what works. And I’m glad you’re here to explore that with me.